Coverage
The public-private debate is changing high school football. But every state is taking a different path.

The conversation is getting louder, and it’s no longer limited to one state or one playoff bracket.
From North Carolina to Illinois to Ohio, school leaders are taking a fresh look at how public, private and other schools without traditional attendance boundaries compete for championships.
The common question is familiar: Is enrollment alone enough to measure competitive balance when schools draw students in different ways?
The answers being considered, though, look very different.
North Carolina: A question of boundaries
North Carolina has not approved a playoff split. It is preparing to discuss whether schools without defined attendance zones should be classified differently in the postseason.
Nash Central principal Jonathan Tribula has asked the NCHSAA to survey its members or study the issue. His proposal offers two broad options: create separate playoff classifications for non-boundary schools, or move those schools into higher classifications based in part on the population around them.
That distinction matters. This is not simply a public-versus-private question. Charter schools are public schools, too, and can draw students without the same neighborhood attendance boundaries as a traditional public school.
The issue is on the agenda for the NCHSAA’s November 30–December 1 meetings. No new playoff format or effective date has been approved.
For football, the debate comes down to what happens when two schools with similar enrollments build their rosters from very different potential student populations. A separate championship path and a move up in classification would address that question in very different ways.
Your team. Your state. Your T25PS.
Make the national coverage more personal.
Save your home state and favorite team, then choose whether to receive major rankings and coverage updates. The account is free.
More Coverage
Coverage
Friday playoff preview: Hough moves on, Northwestern and Ruston face rematches
Hough faces West Forsyth after a 50–14 win, while Northwestern and Ruston get playoff rematches with Dorman and West Monroe.
T25PS / 3 min read
Coverage
Midwest playoff preview: Two unbeaten showdowns and a test for Massillon
Friday brings an unbeaten championship matchup in Wisconsin, an unbeaten semi-state matchup in Indiana and a regional final in Ohio between two teams that have made a habit of shutting opponents down. Here are three games to follow.
T25PS / 2 min read
